Manchester United finally secure Mauricio Pochettino after ten years of narrow misses

Mauricio Pochettino is finally set to become Manchester United’s manager, more than a decade after Sir Alex Ferguson first asked to meet him over lunch. The club’s interest has been on and off since then, and the timing now appears to be right after Michael Carrick was sacked just 15 games into his permanent tenure.

It feels a bit like destiny for Pochettino to end up at Old Trafford. After all, the flirtation between the former Tottenham Hotspur, Paris Saint-Germain and U.S. men’s national team manager and United began more than 10 years ago.

The lunch that started it

In May 2016, amid mounting doubts over Louis van Gaal‘s future, Ferguson asked to meet Pochettino at a London restaurant. Jose Mourinho was already being lined up to replace Van Gaal, but Ferguson still asked the League Managers Association secretary for Pochettino’s number.

The two-hour lunch at Scott’s Restaurant in Mayfair would have stayed private, except the pair, along with Pochettino’s assistant Jesus Perez, were caught by paparazzi on the street outside.

Concerned about the speculation, Tottenham insisted it was just a “social occasion between colleagues.” To quiet the noise further, the club moved up an announcement that Pochettino had verbally agreed to a new five-year contract. Mourinho was confirmed as Van Gaal’s successor weeks later.

United have made five permanent appointments since Pochettino’s meeting with Ferguson, and the former Argentina defender has never been far away.

Waiting in the wings

When Mourinho was sacked in December 2018, Pochettino, who was impressing at Spurs, was considered the top choice for many Old Trafford executives. However, with Pochettino under contract at Tottenham, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer was given the caretaker role to steady the ship. Solskjaer won his first five games, and in January 2019, United travelled to Spurs and won 1-0 to make it six from six.

Sources at United said there was no “defining moment” that decided Solskjaer would get the job permanently, but victory over Pochettino’s Spurs was viewed as “a very positive sign.” Two months later, Solskjaer signed a three-year deal. Pochettino was sacked by Tottenham in November 2019, five months after reaching the UEFA Champions League final.

Out of work and available, Pochettino’s name hung over Solskjaer’s reign every time there was a blip. By January 2021, United bosses admitted they were “relieved” when Pochettino took over at Paris Saint-Germain. The feeling at the time was that the speculation had become a distraction and that Solskjaer would get more breathing space with Pochettino out of the picture as a potential replacement.

Solskjaer lasted another 11 months. When the Norwegian was sacked in November 2021, United opted for another caretaker in Ralf Rangnick. Pochettino was earmarked early on as a potential permanent appointment at the end of the season, but it never materialised.

Close calls and missed chances

Form under Rangnick at the end of the 2021-22 season was so poor that United wanted to lift the mood by announcing a permanent successor before the campaign ended. In the end, it was a close call between Pochettino and Erik ten Hag. Crucially, Ajax allowed Ten Hag to negotiate with United during the season. Locked in a battle for the Ligue 1 title, PSG barred Pochettino from doing the same. That was one of the reasons Ten Hag won the job, and his appointment was announced in April 2022. Pochettino left PSG two months later.

With Ten Hag’s job hanging by a thread after the 2023-24 season, Pochettino was interviewed again. He met the hierarchy shortly after leaving Chelsea in May 2024, but United bosses went away thinking he had been burned by his time at PSG and Stamford Bridge.

Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox, both part of the delegation that met Pochettino, liked him but felt it wasn’t the right moment, and the club eventually stuck with Ten Hag. By the time the Dutchman was finally sacked in October 2024, Pochettino was already in place as head coach of the United States national team, two months into a two-year contract ahead of a home FIFA World Cup.

Pochettino’s credentials were reviewed again towards the end of last season, when Sir Jim Ratcliffe, Berrada and Wilcox were weighing up whether or not to appoint Carrick permanently. Managers at the World Cup, including Pochettino, Thomas Tuchel and Julian Nagelsmann, were initially considered before being ruled out because of timing.

Why now?

Carrick signed a two-year contract in May. Pochettino was still involved at the World Cup until early July, when the U.S. lost to Belgium in the round of 16, just weeks before United’s preseason schedule was due to begin.

With Carrick sacked just 15 games into his permanent tenure, it is finally Pochettino’s turn. There is admiration internally for highly rated young coaches such as Kieran McKenna and Fabian Hürzeler, but there is a feeling that it is not the right time to hire a relatively inexperienced, up-and-coming manager.

Pochettino ticks the boxes for Premier League experience after spells at Southampton, Tottenham and Chelsea, and for big club experience with PSG. He also has history with big players such as Lionel Messi, Neymar and Kylian Mbappé.

Berrada and Wilcox have found him to be re-energised compared with their meeting in 2024, and he has already spoken about his ambition to win the Premier League and the Champions League. Pochettino helped get the move over the line by asking his representatives to inform United of a release clause in the contract extension he signed with the U.S. in August.

United feel it is the right time to appoint Pochettino, whom they consider both tactically astute and a good leader who can handle the glare of the Old Trafford spotlight.

For almost half of his 17-year career in the dugout, Pochettino has been pursued by United, only for the stars to never quite align. A decade on from his lunch with Ferguson, he will finally get the chance to fill his shoes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *